File a Claim

By reporting your loss directly to your insurance company, they can begin to handle all aspects of your claim and get you the help you need when it matters most. If you have a claim to report, you can take advantage of your insurance carrier’s 24/7 claim support service.

Use the menu below to find your insurance company’s online billing, claims and customer service information, reach out to the Rally team for guidance or download our Agentero Policy Service app via the App Store or Google Play for ease of use.

Select insurance company
  • American Collectors Insurance
    American Collectors Insurance
  • American Modern Insurance
    American Modern Insurance
  • Berkshire Hathaway
    Berkshire Hathaway
  • Erie Insurance
    Erie Insurance
  • 	Foremost Insurance Group
    Foremost Insurance
  • Hagerty Insurance
    Hagerty Insurance
  • 	Progressive Insurance
    Progressive Insurance
  • 	Safeco Insurance
    Safeco Insurance

498 Kings Hwy. North
Cherry Hill, NJ 08034
www.americancollectors.com

Customer Service
(800) 360-2277

Claims
(800) 360-2277

7000 Midland Blvd.
Cincinnati, OH 45102
www.amig.com

Customer Service
(800) 543-2644

Claims
(800) 375-2075

Billing
(800) 543-2644

1411 SW Morrison Street
Suite 400
Portland, OR 97205-1945
www.bhhc.com

Customer Service
(877) 383-1742

Claims
(503) 226-4146

100 Erie Insurance Place
Erie, PA 16530
www.erieinsurance.com

Claims
If you have a claim to report, please contact our agency first to help you get started. If you need to file a claim after hours or over the weekend, you can contact ERIE’s 24/7 Claim Support Service directly.
(800) 360-2277
After Hours Claims: (800) 367-3743
24/7 Roadside Service (Agero): (888) 295-5060
ERIEGLASS (Auto Glass Only): (800) 552-3743
Fraud Finders (To Report Fraud): (800) 368-6696

P.O. Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
www.foremost.com

Customer Service
(800) 527-3905

Claims
(800) 527-3907

Billing
1-800-532-4221

141 River’s Edge Drive, #200
Traverse City, MI 49684
www.hagerty.com

Customer Service
1-888-220-9565

Claims
(800) 385-0274

Dept. 0561
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0561
www.progressive.com

Customer Service
888-671-4405
Customers in California: (800) 300-3693

Claims
(800) 776-4737

P.O. Box 6476
Carol Stream, IL 60197
www.safeco.com

Customer Service
(800) 332-3226

Claims
(800) 332-3226

Have a Question?

Check out our FAQ page for the answers you need.

Browse FAQs